The pioneer of what would come to be called intercountry adoption by proxy, Mabel Treadwell Grammer was the founder of an overseas version of the “underground railroad” and a savior to an estimated 500 mixed children born to black GI fathers and European mothers during the occupation of Europe in WWII.
Mabel was born in Hot Springs, Arkansas, in 1914. As a young woman, her talents for writing, her sincerity, and her great drive led her to become a journalist for the Afro-American newspaper in Baltimore. She wrote a successful society column there and was later a civil rights activist, as well as an exceptional beautician and typist.
Mabel’s significant humanitarian efforts did not begin until later in life, some 10 years after she met and married her husband Oscar Grammer. She taught cosmology in Cleveland, and then moved to Washington, D.C. , where she worked as a secretary. While there, she began dating Oscar—a well-dressed, well-groomed, and soft-spoken man. Oscar was a Warrant Officer in the U.S. Army with a steady way of meeting people’s eyes and an inherent friendliness. Both came from very large, loving families. Thus, when Oscar proposed marriage, Mabel felt an obligation to tell him that she was unable to bear children. Oscar waved this off, laughed, and said, “What’s wrong with adopting children?”
In 1951, the U.S. Army transferred Oscar and Mabel to Germany, where Mabel endured episodes of intense headaches. She took several different kinds of pills and often veered in and out of depression. Overwhelmed with pain, she had to call an ambulance to escort her to the hospital. After a medical exam, she was diagnosed as “feeling sorry for herself over her inability to have children.” Her doctor was a woman, a German-Jew who had put herself through medical school only to be sent to a concentration camp by the Nazis. She told Mabel about the horrors of the camp and concluded by saying that, as a result, she, too, could not have children.
The doctor told Mabel about the Kinderheims (orphanages and nurseries) and about the abandoned children that filled them. They were the children of European women and black GI soldiers—so called “brown babies,” children whom no one in Germany wanted.
Mabel soon visited a Kinderheim and found a boy there, not yet five years old, standing alone and wearing nothing but a sheet; sores covered his head and lips. This was Peter. While pursuing his adoption, Peter begged Mabel Grammer to adopt Roswitha as well; and soon after came Wera, and young Mabel, all from the same Kinderheim of St. Josef. The children were all aged four or five.
All of the children were illegitimate, making the legal maneuvers for adoption quite difficult and arousing a lot of German suspicion and disparagement. The German press spun stories that Mabel and Oscar were adopting these children so they could auction them to southern plantations as slaves. In order to adopt, the Grammers had to track down each child’s mother and get her permission, and also prove that the maternal grandfather was a native German. Mabel made the kids an active part of their own adoption, taking them on the car rides down backroads in the German countryside to locate these people and obtain the documentation.
It wasn’t just the Germans who made Mabel navigate through lots of red tape. The U.S. army and the U.S. Consulate required their own special credentials for these children as well. However, it was the German judges who had the final word on the adoptions. One of them became a supporter of Mabel’s cause and deeply admired her faith. When she walked into the courtroom, he would say to her, in precise English, “Here comes Mabel Grammer and her God…” You see, by now Mabel, was practicing her religion through a mission to save these children by assisting to place them in loving homes.
With the addition of Eugenia and Karen, the Grammers became a family of eight. Where their love was seemingly abounding, the Grammer’s finances were finite. Oscar drew an Army salary of $6,000 per year. Mabel was infamous, however, for getting the most out of a buck. She purchased dry goods in 50-pound sacks, and she had a recipe book written by her great-great grandmother called “Poor Man’s Recipes.” One of the recipes, astonishingly, could feed 14 on a single pound of ground beef.
Eventually, the German media started portraying the Grammer’s story in a much more positive light. Soon after, a German teenager showed up at their doorstep with a seven-month-old baby boy. This one happened to be white, though Mabel, of course, was not at all discriminating, and especially not when it came to children; but this child was practically an infant. Mabel suggested the child would be better off with a German family, but the teenage mother was adamant—she wanted her child to go to a home with love in it, and she believed love overflowed in the Grammer’s home. Mabel could not possibly turn the girl away now. She borrowed a crib from a friend, studied up on infant care, and began buying diapers and formula.
Most of the children were adopted by Mabel while Oscar was away on field maneuvers. He came home, often late at night when the house was dark, to find that the small shape in his easy chair—breathing softly, sleeping soundly—was, in fact, a new, unfamiliar child. However, this time Oscar came home to find Mabel holding a seven-month old baby, and his face reflected their already overstretched salary. Quickly, cleverly, Mabel said that the baby boy she held in her arms was “Oscar George Grammer, Jr.
When stories about Mabel’s adoptions were printed in the papers, the Grammers began receiving mail from families requesting her assistance in adopting children in the same manner. In 1955, one of the children Mabel helped find an American home was again orphaned by his new family. Like many before him, Edward became the newest Grammer family member. During the Grammer’s transfer back to D.C., seven-year-old Edward was diagnosed with leukemia. At Christmas, he asked Mabel if there would be a Santa Claus in heaven. A few months later, he passed on, but Mabel was happy that in his last days, she had given him a home away from the orphanage. The Grammer children, under the umbrella of Mabel’s great faith, believed that Edward was happy in heaven and took great pride that hey knew someone “up there.”
A year later, eight-year-old Mack arrived, just after Oscar Sr. returned from Korea. The Grammer kids—all eight of them by this point—would hold mock courts to decide family matters. One such decision was that Mabel adopt yet another boy that Mack had met at the Kinderheim. In 1961, James and his sister Elwin were added to the clan.
Back in Germany, on Easter in 1962, Mabel found an infant on her doorstep holding flowers and a letter. The older Grammer children, having grown in their faith, quickly became champions of their mother’s cause, answering their mother’s mail. Such was their compassion— they wrote one reply of acceptance behind their mother’s back, and Nadja joined the family.
During this time, Mabel was helping place children with U.S. families at an astonishing rate. It’s estimated by the German press that in the first two years of her work, she arranged some 300 adoptions. Other sources put the number closer to 1,000. She did this without the assistance of any agency. Mabel wrote articles urging Black American families to adopt these “beautiful children.” Her old employer, The Baltimore Afro American Magazine, ran regular announcements with pictures of available children and detailing the procedures for adoption. Mabel convinced Scandinavian Airlines to fly the children overseas at reduced rates and to act as temporary guardians of the orphans to assure their safe arrival in the U.S. Scandinavian Airlines called it “the Grammer plan.” Mabel’s mission was becoming a success.
Mabel and Oscar Grammer, who could not biologically have children, ended up with a family of 14. One of the Grammer children, Karen, later gave them two grandchildren. Six of the Grammer children grew up to follow in Oscar’s footsteps by serving in the U.S. armed forces. The Grammer children, now with their own families, reside all across America from Alaska to Florida. Mabel believed that in a country as affluent as America, every child should belong to a home and that orphanages should exist only as homes of transition. She was adamant in her mission and stood her ground in giving these children the opportunity to become Americans.
In 1968, Pope Paul presented Mabel and Oscar with the Pro Ecclesia et Pontifice Medal and the Benemerenti Medal, two of the highest humanitarian awards that can be received. It was the first time such an award was given jointly to a husband and wife.